Michigan Gov. Jennifer Granholm’s laundry list of
job creation “success stories” seems to contain some more dirty laundry in the
basket. This time, Mackinac Center Fiscal Policy Director Michael D. LaFaive
and Communications Specialist Kathy Hoekstra uncovered what looks to be a
fraudulent claim on a solar panel company’s application for tax credits from
the Michigan Economic Growth Authority.
California-based GlobalWatt announced in December 2009
that it chose Saginaw, Mich., over Corpus Christi, Texas, as its new home. Gov.
Granholm made specific mention of this deal in her February 2010 State of the
State address, saying, “In fact, GlobalWatt literally left Silicon Valley in
California to set up shop in an abandoned auto plant in Saginaw.” Initial media
coverage also made much of the fact that it took as much as $42 million in
state and local tax credits to lure GlobalWatt away from Texas. In return,
GlobalWatt promised to create 500 new direct jobs. GlobalWatt claimed on its
MEGA application that Texas had offered “upfront cash incentives” to locate in Corpus Christi.
To investigate this claim, Hoekstra contacted her
counterpart at Texas Watchdog, Mark Lisheron. Lisheron did some digging of his
own, then steered Hoekstra and LaFaive to economic development organizations in
Texas. These agencies confirmed that GlobalWatt’s claims regarding Texas’ cash
offers were false.
On Sept. 29, Hoekstra and LaFaive released an essay and
video highlighting the results of their two-month-long investigation. The essay
and video described the discrepancies between the claims made on GlobalWatt’s
tax credit application and what was offered by Texas. The Saginaw News and
Midland Daily News quickly published stories, as did two Saginaw- and
Flint-area TV stations, WNEM and WJRT.
The story also took root in Texas, with follow-up coverage
by Texas Watchdog and The Corpus Christi Daily Caller. Both outlets were able
to verify Hoekstra and LaFaive’s findings that GlobalWatt’s claims regarding
Texas’ incentive offers were untrue.
GlobalWatt has yet to fulfill its job-creation promises — or
to begin production of solar panel components. In the meantime, the Mackinac
Center will continue to protect Michigan taxpayers by shining sunlight on
questionable “economic development” deals.