The Mackinac Center for Public Policy has obtained a
document outlining details of what would become the "Reform Michigan Government
Now" ballot initiative. The document, in the form of a Microsoft PowerPoint
presentation, bears the blunt title: "GOVERNMENT REFORM PROPOSAL: Changing the
rules of politics in Michigan to help Democrats."
According to the UAW Region 1-C Web site where the document
was originally found,[*] this presentation was given to local union officials at a
leadership conference in late May or early June. UAW officials have not returned our calls, and both the presentation and a brief article that referred
to the presentation have since been removed.
While it’s not clear who delivered the 34-slide
presentation, it begins by painting a grim picture for the Democratic Party in
Michigan. "Democrats have been reduced to a de-facto permanent legislative
minority in Lansing, especially since 1990," the presentation begins. The
document indicates that obtaining favorable Democratic districts would require
Democratic control of Michigan's House, Senate, governor and Supreme Court. The
"problem" is that the Democrats would be unlikely to control future
redistricting, and without favorable redistricting another "Engler era" is
After asserting that Democrats are unlikely to achieve
control of redistricting through conventional means, i.e. the democratic
election of candidates, the presentation outlines a series of changes to remove
"structural obstacles to Democratic control of state government." Among the
goals are the establishment of a bipartisan commission to redraw legislative
boundaries and the removal of two Supreme Court justices and seven Court of
Appeals judges with the intent of establishing a partisan advantage.
To make these changes more palatable to the electorate, the
presentation calls for them to be combined with other alterations to state
government, including a reduction in lawmakers’ salaries, a decrease in
legislative seats and reducing the number of executive branch departments,
state boards and commissions. The amendments suggested in the PowerPoint
presentation match up precisely with the terms of the "Reform Michigan
Government Now" submitted for the November ballot and now under review by the
State Board of Canvassers.
The document also includes polling data and a $4.9 million
budget for passing the initiative, which is described as "less than half the
cost of trying to beat an incumbent GOP Supreme Court Justice." The presentation
concludes with the prediction that "[i]f the proposal passes, it will reduce the
cost and increase the prospects of winning the State Legislature every cycle."
To the extent that this document is what it appears to be,
it leaves little doubt that the Reform Michigan Government Now ballot initiative
is a partisan power play. The most important features of the scheme are the
redistricting commission and the removal of two Republicans from the Michigan
Supreme Court. Nearly everything else in the proposal seems to be calculated to
make the entire package more attractive to voters.
The Mackinac Center is a nonpartisan policy research
organization committed to informing Michigan residents about the content and
likely consequences of legislation and ballot proposals. While we have no
objections to partisan politics as such, it is essential to call attention to
partisan ploys that are presented as neutral good-government reforms.
The PowerPoint file also gives a troubling glimpse into the
thinking of UAW officials. Rather than working to guide their members
through a difficult economy, they appear to be pursuing a crassly partisan and
breathtakingly cynical political maneuver. At a time when the auto industry in
Michigan is undergoing difficult changes, the UAW would be well-advised to focus
on its members and leave politics to the politicians.
The PowerPoint presentation was originally discovered by Mackinac Center Labor Research Intern Jim Vote. That story is told in more detail in "An Intern's Service to Michigan."
Paul Kersey is director of labor policy for the Mackinac
Center for Public Policy, a research and educational institute headquartered in
Midland, Mich. Permission to reprint in whole or in part is hereby granted,
provided that the author and the Center are properly cited.