As Consumers Energy announced that its newest
wind farm had cleared its first hurdle, it also touted the $29 million in
property tax revenue that it is expected to provide to Mason County over the
first 20 years of operation. The Mason County Planning Commission approved a
special land use permit application for the $232 million Lake Winds Energy Park
project last week.
What was left out of the press release was that the project
is expected to receive $72 million in federal tax credits from the federal
stimulus program, the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. Consumers Energy spokesman Dennis Marvin said the $72 million in federal tax credits is expected
to come over a 10-year period.
Critics of wind energy projects say government subsidies
such as the $72 million that Lake Winds will receive are necessary because the
power source itself is too expensive.
“Lake Winds and
other mandated 'renewable' power will simply make energy more
expensive for everyone,” said Pat Michaels, a senior fellow in environmental studies at the Cato Institute, in an email. “Wind and
solar are particularly poor producers of energy, consuming large tracts of land
and producing very little dependable power. If sufficient backup
generation is not available to account for the facts that the wind does not
always blow and the sun does not always shine, then new backup power must be
“This is an
expensive loser for the people of Michigan, and mandating 10 percent of power from
such sources will only create further losses,” Michaels wrote.
Consumers Energy expects Lake Winds to be operational by
the end of 2012. Fifty-six 1.8 megawatt wind turbines will use about 9,300
acres of land in Mason County. The Lake Winds Energy Park is part of the electric
company’s plan to meet a state requirement that 10 percent of their energy come
from Michigan-based "green" projects by 2015.
To help pay for the higher cost of renewable energy, Consumers
Energy customers pay a $2.50 monthly renewable energy surcharge that was
approved by the Michigan Public Service Commission. That charge will drop to 65
cents per month in September.
New "Clean" Energy Law Hikes Costs
“Climate of Extremes: Global Warming Science They Don’t Want You to Know.”
Spending Goes to Black Holes
Flint Loses Out On $1.1 Million
‘Green Energy’ Buses — Now Wants $2.5 Million Version
State Taxpayers May Eat $1.6
Million Loan for Defunct Green Bus Company
Stimulus Boosts Bus Transit
Michigan Pols Approve Stimulus Spending
Blows Open Billion-Dollar State Budget Hole, 'Guaranteed Catastrophe'
Full Time Stimulus Spending - Part Time Work
Michigan Stimulus Recipients Failing to Report – Part 2
$41 Million in Stimulus Money Went Unreported by
Private Home Weatherization a Stimulus Spending Priority