ACLU and Mackinac Center Call on Legislature to Require a Conviction Before Police Can Keep Property

Report shows forfeiture in Michigan typically involves small amounts of money, property taken from people never convicted of a crime

Wednesday, February 21, 2018

Ann Mullen,, 313-400-8562
Jarrett Skorup,, 989-698-1908

DETROIT — The American Civil Liberties Union of Michigan and the Mackinac Center for Public Policy support proposed legislation requiring that a person must first be convicted of a crime before having their property forfeited. The latest asset forfeiture report from state law enforcement agencies shows that more than 700 innocent people had property seized and transferred to the government. The assets typically seized were cars, cash and cell phones and were worth less than $500.

“There are hundreds of people in Michigan every year who are never convicted of crime, but nevertheless have their assets forfeited to the government,” said Jarrett Skorup, director of marketing and strategy at the Mackinac Center. “That’s wrong, and Michigan should join the 14 other states that require the government to prove wrongdoing prior to civil forfeiture.”

State lawmakers require all law enforcement agencies in Michigan to uniformly report information regarding forfeitures to the Michigan State Police. According to the latest report covering most of 2016, 523 people had property forfeited to law enforcement without being charged with a crime. Another 196 were charged and later found innocent, but the government kept their property. Less than half of the 5,290 forfeiture cases in 2016 involved people who were convicted of a crime with most of the rest of the cases involving people still going through the legal process.

“Michigan’s current forfeiture system is ripe for abuse and lawmakers need to protect individual’s property rights and strengthen due process,” said Kim Buddin-Crawford, ACLU of Michigan Policy Counsel. “The current system punishes people even when they have not committed a crime.”

The Michigan Legislature is currently considering House Bill 4158 sponsored by Rep. Peter Lucido, R-Shelby Township. The bill would require a criminal conviction before the government can take ownership of any assets worth less than $50,000. It makes exceptions for plea agreements, if a person dies or is deported, or if assets are abandoned or ownership is unknown.

The bill is currently being reviewed by the Michigan House Judiciary Committee. More information on the legislation, as well as a study on civil asset forfeiture in Michigan authored by policy experts from both the Mackinac Center and ACLU can be found at:

# # # # #