It’s worth a review of MEGA for no other reason than a sage warning against maintaining, resurrecting or creating new subsidy programs. History, experience and a mountain of scholarship shows that such programs are ineffective at creating net new jobs and often just amount to a windfall for corporate interests. The programs are also costly.
I was a mailroom employee of Gov. John Engler when his administration birthed MEGA. I remember distinctly the feeling of being disappointed in the program because it was an about face for the governor. He had previously opposed such programs.
During this episode the Mackinac Center for Public Policy published its first of three formal analyses of the MEGA program, which helped lead to the legislative defeat of the initial proposal. The administration later made a second attempt and MEGA was born. Two days after the legislation was passed by the legislature the Authority announced its first deals, one of which promptly demonstrated at least one reason why the program would later fail: state officials don’t know what they don’t know.
Waldenbooks was offered a tax credit deal worth $7.7 million 25 years ago this coming Monday. To qualify the company had to state in writing that it was the MEGA incentive that made the difference in the firm’s decision to relocate to Michigan.
But news reporters quickly learned and published the fact that executives for the company had put down deposits on homes in the Ann Arbor area before MEGA had even been passed into law. They were apparently coming here anyway and just went looking for a taxpayer-funded windfall. Waldenbooks went bankrupt, released their subsidized employees and closed their Ann Arbor location in the last year of eligibility for their MEGA incentive.
The state’s corporate handout complex made other blunders in trying to pick winners from losers in the marketplace. In December, 1999 — at the height of the dot.com boom — Webvan Group, Inc., was offered a MEGA tax credit deal of $23.4 million to locate a warehouse in the Motor City. The then head of the Michigan Economic Development Corporation proudly said Webvan was “… one of the best-financed retailers on the market for the next wave of e-retailing.” The company stock never closed higher and it filed for bankruptcy in 2001. Fortunately, it never collected on its MEGA incentives.
These examples are instructive, but criticism of the MEGA program has gone much further. Two Mackinac Center studies (2005 and 2009) found a zero to negative impact on MEGA-related employment. Of the three MEGA-specific studies not performed by the Mackinac Center, produced similar findings. The last was more positive. A December 2018 academic study praised Gov. Snyder for reining in state incentives and described the MEGA program as a “debacle.”
All the dollars dedicated to the MEGA program came with a direct opportunity cost, or the next best opportunity foregone. What might we have done with the billions wasted by the program:? Invest them in better roads? Cut the personal income tax rate? Spend it fighting the effects of today’s COVID-19 pandemic?
Thankfully the program is mostly part of Michigan’s history now and not its future. Taxpayers and lawmakers should be wary of those state subsidy programs that still exist, still waste taxpayer dollars and still pile up lost opportunities.
Permission to reprint this blog post in whole or in part is hereby granted, provided that the author (or authors) and the Mackinac Center for Public Policy are properly cited.
Permission to reprint any comments below is granted only for those comments written by Mackinac Center policy staff.
Get insightful commentary and the most reliable research on Michigan issues sent straight to your inbox.
The Mackinac Center for Public Policy is a nonprofit research and educational institute that advances the principles of free markets and limited government. Through our research and education programs, we challenge government overreach and advocate for a free-market approach to public policy that frees people to realize their potential and dreams.
Please consider contributing to our work to advance a freer and more prosperous state.