
Government-run unemployment insurance has long been designed to financially assist people who lose their job through no fault of their own. Michigan’s unemployment system has a problem, however. It may favor employees over employers during the appeals process when there is a question of whether an individual qualifies for unemployment compensation. The state should bring greater clarity to the appeals process by replacing its broad judicial standard for more specific statutory provisions that are objective and evenhanded.
Some background is in order. The federal-state unemployment insurance system is primarily financed through taxes on employers. It was born under federal law, with states developing their own laws that must comply with federal rules. Employers pay both federal and state unemployment taxes.
An employee who is turned out of a job may be eligible to file a claim for unemployment compensation with the Michigan Unemployment Insurance Agency, which will determine whether the former employee should be paid. If either employer or employee protests the agency’s decision, the agency issues a redetermination. Either party can then appeal that decision and seek a hearing before an administrative law judge within the Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affaris. It is at this formal appeals stage that Michigan employees receive unusually favorable outcomes, according to federal data.
In April, the Mackinac Center examined U.S. Department of Labor data, seeking to know how often former employees succeeded in reversing an initial ruling against them. Michigan ranked fifth out of 50 states. A former employee in Michigan who disputed an unfavorable ruling had a 32% higher chance of succeeding than the average former employee across the nation. When employers appealed the state’s determination, by contrast, Michigan ranked 42nd in its share of reversals, or 18% lower than the national average.
Data for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2025, showed that Michigan employees who seek a reversal of an unfavorable decision succeed 38% of the time, compared to the national average of 35%. The rate is also higher than that found in our close neighboring states of Ohio (30%), Indiana (29%), Illinois (27%) and Wisconsin (24%).
When employers appeal determinations at the lower level in Ohio and Indiana, they win at a higher rate than they do Michigan: more than one-third of the time, compared to 28% of the time in Michigan.
It is difficult to pinpoint one specific cause for this reported imbalance toward employees in appeals decisions. One plausible explanation is Michigan’s broad judicial standard of “misconduct,” described in a 1961 Michigan Supreme Court decision. This leaves decisions open to broader interpretation, which is hard for employers, given that Michigan’s Unemployment Insurance Agency places the burden on them to prove misconduct.
Indiana, by contrast, embeds more standards in statute. Its lawbooks include unemployment-disqualifying “just cause” terms such as “refusal to obey instructions.” Wisconsin once relied on a broad judicial definition of misconduct before codifying definitions that included specific circumstances such as absenteeism and tardiness. Ohio also uses “just cause” language in its statute, although courts still play an important role in defining specific conduct that might disqualify an employee from receiving benefits.
The comparisons suggest that the Michigan Legislature could reasonably improve the apparent imbalance in appeals decisions. Giving employers, workers and administrative law judges more specific statutory guidance about what conduct should disqualify a worker from unemployment benefits would be a good start.
Other possible reasons for imbalances in the system go beyond the scope of this essay, but they include an unusual additional layer of administrative review that takes place before a disputed decision reaches a formal appeals hearing. Another factor is the comparatively formal treatment of evidence at appeal hearings.
Michigan runs an advocacy program for employees and employers that helps both appeal unemployment insurance decisions, but the law provides an asymmetric advantage to employees who make a claim. It says that the program’s cost of dealing with employee claims “must not exceed 60%” of its appropriated fund while the cost spent dealing with employers “must not exceed 40%.” That gives spending on employee claimants a statutory expenditure ceiling 50% higher than that for employers.
Michigan’s statute lists a few specific offenses that would disqualify an employee’s claim, but it leaves the catch-all ‘misconduct’ undefined, relying on a 1961 judicial standard. Lawmakers should clearly define in statute what conduct disqualifies workers from benefits. Clearer statutory standards would give workers better notice of what conduct could disqualify them from benefits, while giving employers and judges firmer guidance for resolving disputes.
Permission to reprint this blog post in whole or in part is hereby granted, provided that the author (or authors) and the Mackinac Center for Public Policy are properly cited.
Get insightful commentary and the most reliable research on Michigan issues sent straight to your inbox.
The Mackinac Center for Public Policy is a nonprofit research and educational institute that advances the principles of free markets and limited government. Through our research and education programs, we challenge government overreach and advocate for a free-market approach to public policy that frees people to realize their potential and dreams.
Please consider contributing to our work to advance a freer and more prosperous state.
Donate | About | Blog | Pressroom | Publications | Careers | Site Map | Email Signup | Contact