According to the Detroit Free Press, the city of Detroit must make a $195 million balloon payment to its pension systems in 2024, which is some 71 percent higher than the amount approved in city’s bankruptcy plan. New hiring, delayed pension cuts, and longer life expectancies have left the city responsible for a growing retirement-benefit liability.
Statewide, the situation is not much better. Recent financial statements for pension plans covering Michigan’s state employees, teachers and police officers indicate that those plans are underfunded by some $33 billion, an increase of about $1.5 billion over last year. Adding insult to injury, the state estimates that health and other retirement benefits for those same employees are underfunded by another $21 billion.
Taken together, that’s almost $5,400 per capita — and there is no sign of improvement on the horizon.
Most private sector employers have attacked their pension funding challenges by moving employees into defined contribution plans, such as 401(k) or 403(b) accounts. Starting in 1997, the state of Michigan joined them – but only for new state government employees. The Mackinac Center found that this move reduced pension costs by $167 million and helped the state avoid accruing as much as $4.3 billion in unfunded pension liabilities. Michigan is not the only state to achieve savings from defined contribution plans. Studies from the Manhattan Institute and multiple peer-reviewed journals find that defined contribution plans have lower contribution costs, administrative costs, or both.
Not surprisingly, about 80 percent of the state’s unfunded pension liabilities have accrued in the public school employee pension plan that made no such transition. To get the situation under control, it’s time Michigan transitioned public school employees into a defined-contribution plan. The move would reduce costs, control liabilities and eliminate a number of pension-specific perverse incentives that put taxpayers at risk for unforeseen costs.
Permission to reprint this blog post in whole or in part is hereby granted, provided that the author (or authors) and the Mackinac Center for Public Policy are properly cited.
Permission to reprint any comments below is granted only for those comments written by Mackinac Center policy staff.