Teacher Who Never Wanted Union Representation Still Forced To Be A Member

Saginaw art teacher said he was not told he had only one month to exercise his rights

Comment Print Mail ShareFacebook Twitter More
Matt Knapp is an art teacher at Ruben Daniels Middle School in Saginaw.

When Matt Knapp was hired as a teacher in the Saginaw Public School district 11 years ago, he said he was given paperwork to sign to be a union member.

"Oh, no," Knapp said he told the district employee. "I'd rather not be in the union."

To his surprise, he was told it was a condition of employment.

That changed last year when Michigan became a right-to-work state, which allows union members the freedom to choose whether they want to pay dues or fees to the union. When that happened, Knapp said he approached his union about how to opt out.

He said he was told he missed the August window to leave, the only time the Michigan Education Association allows members to opt out. Knapp said he did not know that was the only time of the year he could leave.

Knapp filed an unfair labor complaint along with six other teachers with the Michigan Employment Relations Commission against their local unions and the MEA. The Mackinac Center Legal Foundation is representing the teachers.

Knapp, 46, is an art teacher at Ruben Daniels Middle School in Saginaw.

"This has nothing to do with my school or the Saginaw district," Knapp said. "I've not been a large supporter of the union to begin with, and when the right-to-work action passed, I was excited about it. I was not notified about a deadline. I'm trying to leave the union gracefully if they will let me. I think that the union's responsibility is to fight for the right of the worker, and my right is to not be part of the union. … That is one right they won't protect, apparently."

Stay Engaged

Receive our weekly emails!

Saginaw Education Association President Leann Bauer and Michigan Education Association UniServ Director for Saginaw Sue Rutherford didn't respond to requests for comment.

The teachers involved in the lawsuit against their unions include:

  • Miriam Chanski, a kindergarten teacher in Coopersville who is a member of the Coopersville Education Association;
  • William "Ray" Arthur, a high school teacher in Petoskey who is a member of the Petoskey Education Association;
  • Matthew Knapp, an art teacher at Ruben Daniels Middle School and member of the Saginaw Education Association;
  • Kurt Alliton, a technology teacher at the Thompson Middle School and member of the Saginaw Education Association;
  • Susan Romska, a geometry teacher at Arthur Hill High School and member of the Saginaw Education Association; 
  • Jason LaPorte, a social studies teacher at Arthur Hill High School and member of the Saginaw Education Association;
  • Kathy Eady-Miskiewicz, an English teacher at Arthur Hill High School and a member of the Saginaw Education Association.


A video report about Matt and the teachers in Saginaw suing the union:


See also:

Teachers Sue MEA To Escape Union

Union Threatens Hall of Fame Coach With Legal Action For Not Paying Dues

CapCon Right-to-Work Coverage

Know Your Rights: MI Worker Freedom


Related Articles:

Teacher Claims Union Ruined Her Credit, Humiliated Her Over Trying to Leave

RTW 'Freeloader' Claim Still a Farce

Lawsuit Filed Against MEA Over Dues Policies, 'Fair Representation'

Teachers Contract Contains Questionable Forced Unionization Clause

Court of Appeals Denies MEA’s Request to Keep ‘August Window’

Teachers Victorious Over MEA

Stay Engaged

Simply enter your email below to receive our weekly email:


Ted Nelson is a retired Michigan State Police officer who trained police departments throughout the state on civil asset forfeiture. He believes the practice has been misused and needs to change.

Related Sites